RSS

Where Butterflies and Alzheimers Might Meet

24 Dec

(On Strangler Figs)


Time to speculate:

Butterflies often use toxic plants as caterpillar hosts.  The larvae take up poisons from the host plant and become protectively poisonous, the safety shield carrying over into adulthood.  Monarchs feed on milkweeds able to stop a predator’s heart.   Pipevine and the Polydamas Swallowtails who eat them kill cells.   Zebra Longwings obtain cyanide from their passionvine.   Could go on, but we all get the point.   But now comes a minor mystery, the Ruddy Daggerwing Butterfly and Ficus.

Ruddy Daggerwing on Jack-in-theBush

For most common creatures the Internet reveals a ton of research.     But try that for the mysterious Ruddy Daggerwing Butterfly.  Yes, there are tidbits, but what the knowledge-seeker learns quickly it is how under-studied this beautiful creature is, at least via normal Internet snooping.   Maybe there’s deep research out there in dusty tomes or secret catacombs.

Its larval hosts are members of the fig genus, Ficus.   At least toward the northern part of the butterfly’s small range, mainly Strangler Fig.    The Daggerwing’s distribution and that of the Strangler Fig are virtually the same.

Ruddy Daggerwing, from butterfliesandmoths.org
Strangler Fig, Biota of N America

Do figs pass poisons to Ruddy Daggerwing caterpillars like those milkweeds, pipevines, and passionvines do to their caterpillar partners?  Ficus drips milky sap when broken, and in a general sense we don’t trust milky sap.   Also, you don’t often see much insect damage on Strangler Fig foliage.    But specifically, is there something nasty, and what might it be?

There might be something very insecticidal,  and to go farther we need some context on cholinesterase inhibitors.   Cholinesterase (colon-ES-ter-aze)  is a key enzyme in an insect’s and my nervous system.  Inhibit cholinesterase, and you inhibit nerve function.     They are central to today’s story.

Most of the late 20th Century insecticides were cholinesterase inhibitors. So are certain military “nerve agents.” They kill bugs and humans.

Most attention in treating Alzheimers centers on cholinesterase inhibitors. They might be useful to humans when properly harnessed.

Most recent attention to the biochemistry of Ficus centers on its cholinesterase inhibitors in relation to potential Alzheimers treatments.

So then, it looks at a glance  that perhaps the Ruddy Daggerwing can tolerate and sequester the fig’s cholinesterase inhibitors as its own borrowed secret weapon.

Sounds good to me.  All that’s missing is evidence.


Merry Christmas
 
6 Comments

Posted by on December 24, 2021 in Uncategorized

 

6 responses to “Where Butterflies and Alzheimers Might Meet

  1. Diane Goldberg's avatar

    Diane Goldberg

    December 25, 2021 at 7:36 am

    I found your blog on Butterflies and Alzheimers very interesting, but I didn’t understand about Pipevine and the Swallowtails who eat them kill cells. What cells do the swallowtails kill or is it the pipevine that kills cells? Sorry, I’m very confused. Also, if Zebra Longwings obtain cyanide from their passionvine do Gulf Fritillaries and Julias too.

     
    • George Rogers's avatar

      George Rogers

      December 25, 2021 at 8:51 am

      Hi Diane. On the cell killing. The Aristocochla poisons are dreadful directly from the vine. The Polydamas (and Pipevine Swallowtail) caterpillars take in the toxins from the plant which gives the caterpillars protection, this carrying over into adulthood. I have in hand data showing cyanide in Longwings, which is why they were featured. Offhand I’m not certain abut Gulf Fritillaries and Julias, but have not researched them at all, not even quick Google (but now will). I’ll bet they have cyanide too, just did not want to say so without data..

       
      • Diane Goldberg's avatar

        Diane Goldberg

        December 25, 2021 at 9:35 am

        Hi George, do you mean that the toxins kill cells in whatever eats the caterpillars or butterflies? I’m looking forward to your research on Gulf Fritillaries and Julias.
        Merry Christmas

         
  2. habitatsp@aol.com's avatar

    habitatsp@aol.com

    December 25, 2021 at 10:50 am

    Hi George,

    Wishing you and your family a very Merry Holiday Season! Keep writing those new posts. Very interesting! We caught the Covid bug but got 3 shots and are recovering well.

    Stay safe and well!

    Cheers

    Chris

     
    • George Rogers's avatar

      George Rogers

      December 25, 2021 at 2:26 pm

      Merry Christmas and speedy recovery Chris!

       
  3. Rachel Cavanaugh's avatar

    Rachel Cavanaugh

    December 25, 2021 at 8:05 pm

    Interesting! A good sleuthing assignment!
    Merry Christmas to you and yours🎄

     

Leave a comment